L.,
I understand the feeling...While I haven't seriously considered this as an option for my husband and myself, the thought has crossed my mind. Like you, we both make decent money, but seem to have no money for many things. I'm not even talking about going out to eat, etc. I'm talking about things like paying bills on time and making full payments.
Our situation came to a head a few nights ago when we had our gas shut off because we were two months behind with payments. We were able to scrape the money together to make a payment and get it turned back on, but it really made us take a look at what was going on.
I have a certain set of bills to pay out of my paycheck and my husband has a certain set to pay out of his. I had been telling him that I am paying out more than I am making, but he didn't believe it for some reason.
So, we made out a detailed list of how much we make and all the bills we take care of. It turns out that I am definately paying out more than I make. We haven't come to a complete agreement about how we're going to handle the situation, but at least we know what our situation is now and we can work on it.
Anyway, I guess what I'm trying to get at is, before you make this decision (which is HUGE), take a look at your incomes vs. expenses. You might be able to make some adjustments.
I have some freinds who filed for bankruptcy and it "fixed" their problems by wiping away their debts, but the law has recently changed. I'm not sure of all the details, but to my knowledge, with the new laws, you still have to pay back all your debts. It's not like it used to be and it doesn't give you the fresh start many people think. My friends pay cash for everything now, which is probably better for them, but it's very hard to get loans, etc now.
You might pay out more in the end with interest, but one option I have have been considering is loan consolidation. This would put all debts into one monthly payment, lower than all the individual loans.
Just some thoughts. Good luck and let us know what what you decide will work for you. I have a feeling a lot of us are in the same boat!