M.
I don't think it is weird. I am the same way, but not to that extreme. I think of it more like lotion just makes me happy. Like you, I am picky about the smell, but not AS picky. I love to have scented lotions, if I LIKE the scent. And I am the same way about lip stuff too. But I'm pretty picky there too. I like Nivea at the moment. I say don't let it bother you...if you like lotion...use lotion!