C.C.
I would stick with middle of the road stuff. Gap, Old Navy, that type of thing is good at this age. My daughter is going into 4th, and she wants to go to Justice too, but I don't really love the clothes there. She does have a few Abercrombie and Roxy things, and we mix those in with the Old Navy items, and she has been happy with that so far. Nobody has made fun of her. I think you're on the right track with allowing her to choose her outfits to a certain extent. It's important that kids like and feel comfortable with what they're wearing, and can make it their own, style-wise. Also, I will say that my kids don't own a ton of clothes. You don't need that many things to make up a bunch of cute looks, if you get things in the same color palette.