My two older boys did the same thing. The oldest one preferred chewing on his fingers and an icy teething ring. My middle boy preferred the harder side of his pacifier. I'd stock up on teething rings and things that she could gnaw on.
I also had a burp cloth type thing that has 4 firm rubber corners with different colors and textures embossed into it. The younger two loved that. I think I found it at Reasor's. Babies R Us does't show on on line the stuff they show would be great though. There's a picture of one at this ebay auction place: (I have no affiliation with the seller) http://cgi.ebay.com/NWT-2-Sassy-Teething-Bibs-and-1-Teeth...
I checked the walmar, walgreen's and target websites and don't see anything like it but Target has some toys that would work.
Skip the tylenol if you can. Use it only at nap times and bed time, This is the time to get her on a good sleep/eating schedule. Move up to a firmer nipple on the bottle can help too.
Don't be surprised if she cuts one a month for the next year. Some kids do. Runny noses, sore throats and ear infections always accompanied my boys teeth.